Ice is just a different form of water.
It is a matter of definition, and the way the author interprets it is not the same as in chemistry. So any of you voting "no" are simply confused.
if they're not in basic table of elements then they aren't elements and if they aren't elements then they definitely cannot be the same elements
'Ice is made from water, and yet is colder than water.' (Xunzi 1.1)
Ice is the same the same as water but they are both compounds not elements (H2O). They are made up of one oxygen atom bonded to 2 hydrogen atoms. Why is this a poll its not something that can be debated its a fact.
Neither are elements so
Ice and water in games are differnt elements. Ice usally freezes opponenets and water is good against fire.