If god can do anything, can god create a rock so heavy he cannot lift it?

Posted by: discomfiting

Omnipotence paradox

Vote
17 Total Votes
1

Yes

8 votes
7 comments
2

If a being can perform any action, then it should be able to create a task which this being is unable to perform; hence, this being cannot perform all actions. Yet, on the other hand, if this being cannot create a task that it is unable to perform, then there exists something it cannot do.

6 votes
1 comment
3

No

3 votes
3 comments
Leave a comment...
(Maximum 900 words)
madness says2014-06-06T20:08:09.8414375-05:00
I think I made this exact poll like a week ago. (Mine is much better.)
discomfiting says2014-06-06T20:08:45.5108577-05:00
No
Auragirl360 says2014-06-06T20:12:06.3687141-05:00
That would create a paradox. He wouldn't be able to lift it, because he made it that way, BUT he can do anything, so he COULD lift it. But he can't. But he can. Paradox.
madness says2014-06-06T20:15:58.9099228-05:00
Meaning that Gods power has limits ^
MyDinosaurHands says2014-06-06T20:20:16.0624068-05:00
I'd answer this, but my brain has exploded.
voxprojectus says2014-06-06T21:34:25.7897893-05:00
So God's existence is already a paradox in its nature. God, already being an impossible thing, can do impossible things, therefore, simply put, God can make a rock that is so heavy he cannot move it, and then he can move it anyway. That's how omnipotence works.
SamStevens says2014-06-06T22:44:35.5422590-05:00
My question is which God is this poll about? There are hundreds of Gods out their, so a little specification would be nice.
spinalcordreactor says2014-06-06T23:12:01.9704387-05:00
Madness your polls always suck so it's hard to gage which polls suck more.
spinalcordreactor says2014-06-06T23:12:29.6292387-05:00
Who gives a sh*t?
spinalcordreactor says2014-06-06T23:26:02.4172924-05:00
"Reason is, and ought only to be the slave of the passions"
Fight4Liberty says2014-06-07T01:26:56.7112157-05:00
It's really not complicated; God could create a rock too heavy to lift beyond his power at the time, but then advance His powers to a higher level.
Kerfluffer says2014-06-07T15:56:26.7122408-05:00
God can create a rock that He cannot lift. However, He is SO powerful that He can still lift it anyway.
jaksunmadness says2014-06-08T01:45:47.3541899-05:00
If he can do anything.... Then the statement made after that is invalid he can then lift the rock he couldnt lift because he can do ANYTHING
SweetTea says2014-06-08T16:10:31.5732712-05:00
Jesus looked at them and said, “With man this is impossible, but with God all things are possible.” -- Matthew 19:26

Freebase Icon   Portions of this page are reproduced from or are modifications based on work created and shared by Google and used according to terms described in the Creative Commons 3.0 Attribution License.

By using this site, you agree to our Privacy Policy and our Terms of Use.