Is sexuality genetic?

Posted by: zidzad1

I would love this to be seen debated however i don't believe I the biological knowledge in genetics nor do i know or am homosexual myself, but anyway is being gay a choice?

  • Yes

  • No

37% 7 votes
63% 12 votes
  • It is shaped by both in my opinion nature and nurture.

  • There is no gay or straight gene. But recently, scientists have found that on sex chromosome X, there may be some genetic influence of sexual orientation. I'm gay and at no time did i make a decision to be straight or gay, I'm sure none of you guys did. If you did, maybe your just asexual. So many tests, especially those of the brain, have repeatedly proven sexual orientation to not be a choice. What causes someone's sexual orientation is likely something not environmental. I say that because people say people become gay if they are molested by a pedophile as a young child. This is absurd. Mostly because I personally know no gay men to whom this has happened to, but i do know straight men whom have had this happened to them. The theories that people propose suggesting environment influences sexual orientation is quite inconsistent. Now i do believe that environment can influence fetishes. If you study the Polynesia cultures that wear no clothes, the men and women have no fetishes and they aren't constantly staring at each other's genitalia. In fact their societies are LESS decadent due to wearing no clothes, because sex is not a taboo subject and filled with all kinds of crap.

    Posted by: UCS123
  • No evidence. The human DNA genome was decoded in 2001.

  • But research suggests that it may have genetic factors involved.

  • Homosexuality is the desire for someone of the same gender as you. It is scientifically impossible for 2 men or 2 women to have a child together. If people with a "gay gene" were born gay they would not have sex (meaning that they couldn't have kids). Thus, if there was a gene for gayness, it would not be passed on. The gene, if it ever existed, would have died out after the first generation. If gayness is a recessive trait, then its increase in the general population would be illogical (real recessive traits like blue eyes have become less common in America over the years). Furthermore if you were born either gay or normal, how could bisexuals be explained? The only way would be through incomplete or codominance. If that was the case, then, in order to be straight, one would have to be homozygous for heterosexuality. As a result, it would be impossible for 2 straight parents to have a gay child. Thus, it is illogical to conclude that homosexuality is genetic.

Leave a comment...
(Maximum 900 words)
ESocialBookworm says2014-03-29T20:31:08.1920737-05:00
Idk... Does it matter?
Fanath says2014-03-29T20:40:29.5616722-05:00
Yeah, so idiots don't go around claiming you can pray away the gay or whatever...
Valtin says2014-03-29T21:06:46.9015522-05:00
No.
Conservative101 says2014-03-29T21:13:38.0284187-05:00
People have gone from homo to hetero. And vice versa. It's happened before. People can't go from male to female (they can try, but their DNA will remain the same).
etherealvoyager says2014-03-29T21:22:52.5262017-05:00
Partly genetic.
Jingram994 says2014-03-29T22:11:56.6286503-05:00
Actual sexuality, as in, actual sexual attraction, has been shown to have epigenetic (essentially, genetics being acted on by the environment in the womb) causes. Unlike some people are implying, it is not possible to 'go from homo to hetero'. Or vice versa. These people are either bisexual, or sexually confused, or (consciously or subconsciously) 'hiding' their actual sexuality. Also, someone clearly isn't aware of the distinction between sex and gender.
Macgreggor says2014-03-29T22:51:35.9888395-05:00
Yeah jing that has happened so many times, I have in 55 years of being hetero often thought oh, look I think Iwill be gay, that guy is sooo cute. Wtf?
WaterTipper says2014-03-29T22:58:25.8712012-05:00
@Mcacgreggor: Intrusive thoughts. Anxiety. Subconscious homophobia. Bi-curiousness. Pick your poison
SNP1 says2014-03-30T10:54:36.7670224-05:00
In a way, it is both. It is EPI-genetic, which directly relates to genetics while not actually being genetics.
UCS123 says2014-04-02T20:54:29.0866917-05:00
Conservative logic doesn't know what he's talking about....
jery1569 says2014-04-03T16:34:29.7567683-05:00
Of course it is. What a silly question.
jery1569 says2014-04-03T16:47:09.6109079-05:00
@conservativelogic-You should have said procreate, not sex. I know a gay guy with 3 kids because he donated his sperm. It's not impossible for 2 straight parents to have a gay child. My ex-girlfriend's son is gay and he has 2 straight parents. Homosexuality IS genetic.

Freebase Icon   Portions of this page are reproduced from or are modifications based on work created and shared by Google and used according to terms described in the Creative Commons 3.0 Attribution License.

By using this site, you agree to our Privacy Policy and our Terms of Use.