Should Washington DC be granted statehood?

Posted by: imabench

All of its laws are subjected directly to Congress, making the Capital of the US ironically the one place in the continental US that has taxation without representation

16 Total Votes


10 votes
1 comment


6 votes
Leave a comment...
(Maximum 900 words)
TBR says2015-08-03T15:42:39.5854471Z
Funny, this came up the other day with a user who I will not name. He said the reason we should destroy social security was because it was "taxation without representation". After gathering the shatters of my brain, I thought, there ARE a handful (~600k) Americans that CAN say this.
TBR says2015-08-03T15:57:36.7159979Z
I would love to hear from a no vote. I for the life of me cant understand the justification for this.
stargate says2015-08-03T20:43:43.5496410Z
Well it just dosn't make any sense to make it a state. Now yeah there are some benefits, but in my eyes it dosn't really need statehood. Also in my opinion it is way to small to be a state. I would rather have gurm, or purto rico become states.
TBR says2015-08-03T22:30:48.9265214Z
Well, as noted above, it has a larger population than two other states currently in the union. The other obvious issue is, they are the only Americans without representation in congress. That is a big issue.
TBR says2015-08-03T22:32:08.5321515Z
Just looked it up, Beats Guam's population by several times.
IndependentTruth says2015-08-03T22:50:55.7797774Z
We shouldnt make it a state cause 50 states sounds better than 51
stargate says2015-08-03T23:55:24.9165794Z
Um, yeah but can't it just be part of maryland, or virgania? I mean it is just way to small to be a state. Also you are say washington dc witch is a city. So that state would have one city, and thata it. I am sorry but it is just dumb to make that small area a state. It should instead be counted as maryland, or virgania when it comes to voteing.
TBR says2015-08-03T23:59:00.8392437Z
Those are not solutions without merit. The only point I would belabor would be "size". Again, it is not that small, and hence, this is not a trivial mater.
stargate says2015-08-04T00:12:29.2988261Z
Um...I guess, but I am more undersized. But lets face it, it will not happen.
TBR says2015-08-04T00:14:05.5965632Z
Its no more a long-shot than Guam. Well, I would get it much better chance than Guam.
imabench says2015-08-04T04:57:27.5839496Z
Stargate you realize that guam is only three times the size of DC right? To say DC is too small to be a state but then believe Guam should be a state is completely hypocritical
58539672 says2015-08-04T06:03:25.4090003Z
The only argument that I can think of to why DC should not be a state would be that the constitution does say that the Capital will be its own district under the direct control of congress.
greatkitteh says2015-08-04T13:30:31.5392695Z
Uf DC is a state, Then Guam shoyld be as well to coubter-act a denocrat advantige.

Freebase Icon   Portions of this page are reproduced from or are modifications based on work created and shared by Google and used according to terms described in the Creative Commons 3.0 Attribution License.

By using this site, you agree to our Privacy Policy and our Terms of Use.