Was the NBA's punishment of Donald Sterling fair?

Posted by: melbaski

Is $2.5 million, a lifetime ban and a campaign to force Sterling to sell his NBA team, the Clippers, justified based on racist remarks he made to his girlfriend during a personal conversation?

Poll closed on 5/30/2014 at 12:00AM.
  • Yes, absolutely, the NBA was fully justified in their actions and should fight to have all their penalties upheld.

  • No, absolutely not, the NBA overstepped their authority and are violating his rights.

41% 7 votes
59% 10 votes
  • If Sterling breached a contract by foolishly allowing himself to be recorded and then incompetently looking after those recordings then the NBA is quite justified in their actions.

  • Donald Sterling violated the most important rule of running a business: respect your customers/treat your clients like gold. He failed to do this big time so now the league owners have every right to punish him severely to communicate to fans of every race--particularly black fans and atheletes--that they matter to the sport!

  • The NBA has overreacted and clearly has a double standard. They have let black players make derogatory comments about whites in public forums with no consequences. Their attempts to strong arm an owner into tolerance over comments he made in a private conversation is intolerant and therefor hypocritical. His opinions may be unpopular and offensive, but he has a right to have them.

  • While the NBA has every right to do this, I think that it was unnecessary to punish him so harshly for a single unsavory comment in a private conversation.

  • Three important reasons, number one, freedom of speech. Many Black NBA players make derogatory statements regarding whites with no penalty, so there should be no double standard. Sterling pays his players Millions of dollars to play on his franchise, so he's not really a "racist" it he? And finally, a recording of him being leaked is not necessarily the most fair and legal way to get something out there, everyone turn in all their voicemails and see how many people get in trouble.

Leave a comment...
(Maximum 900 words)
Crescendo says2014-05-02T21:22:08.5407712-05:00
He needed to be fired because the controversy would otherwise hurt the team if left undealt with. Also, I agree that his comments were racist. However, it was indeed a private conversation. Unless he himself revealed the contents of that tape to the world, what he said there should've stayed there and not have been unveiled to the world. In their zeal to put an end to racism, what people forget is that freedom of speech still exists in this country. Under freedom of speech Sterling had the right to say all that he said in private. The only reason that he should be fired is because word of this got out and there's a huge controversy over it. He should not have been fined; just fired.
Juan_Pablo says2014-05-03T01:19:09.6747358-05:00
Donald Sterling violated the most important rule of running a business: respect your customers/treat your clients like gold. He failed to do this big time so now the league owners have every right to punish him severely to communicate to fans of every race--particularly black fans and atheletes--that they matter to the sport! If you don't understand how important this matters in the NBA or any major league sport, but all means, DON'T RUN a professional sports team!

Freebase Icon   Portions of this page are reproduced from or are modifications based on work created and shared by Google and used according to terms described in the Creative Commons 3.0 Attribution License.

By using this site, you agree to our Privacy Policy and our Terms of Use.