What was the biggest mistake of the Iraq war (2003-2011)?

Posted by: Unknown95

We messed up bad with this war but what was our biggest mistake?

Vote
19 Total Votes
1

Other

11 votes
9 comments
2

No exit plan

6 votes
0 comments
3

Backed a bad leader

2 votes
0 comments
4

Poor military strategy

0 votes
0 comments
5

Poor public relations

0 votes
0 comments
Leave a comment...
(Maximum 900 words)
TBR says2015-06-16T12:12:18.9229002-05:00
So hard to find just one.
shalal12 says2015-06-16T14:48:52.3029347-05:00
It was full of big mistakes from beginning to end.
FreedomBeforeEquality says2015-06-17T14:40:41.2881922-05:00
Leaving!
58539672 says2015-06-17T18:44:21.8084321-05:00
@FreedomBeforeEquality Yeah, not the best move on our part.
TBR says2015-06-19T09:13:01.4397364-05:00
@FreedomBeforeEquality - Leaving would not have been an issue if we had never gone.
FreedomBeforeEquality says2015-06-19T11:24:31.6982775-05:00
The middle east would have still been an issue though.
FreedomBeforeEquality says2015-06-19T11:25:07.8753732-05:00
And would not have been an issue any longer if we had played things out fully.
TBR says2015-06-19T11:25:37.1682316-05:00
So what? We have NEVER made it any better by intervening.
FreedomBeforeEquality says2015-06-19T11:26:41.6102744-05:00
Nothing would have been solved by not taking the leap. Nothing was solved by backing down.
TBR says2015-06-19T11:26:52.7249895-05:00
"And would not have been an issue any longer if we had played things out fully." Right... That has been said every time we mess stuff up. Lets learn from our obvious mistakes this time.
TBR says2015-06-19T11:27:14.0349993-05:00
What needs to be "solved" by us?
FreedomBeforeEquality says2015-06-19T11:36:28.6724652-05:00
Wheres you conscience at now, about buying oil from a dictator like that? People protest purchasing (and subsequently supporting) from wicked people all the time, but when it comes to where we get our gas ... Then its suddenly OK. It didn't need to be all us doing the solving (and it wasn't ... Many nations backed out intent also). Those people were crying out to be saved from that regime. Now their crying to be saved from radicals too. The only thing that makes it remotely look like a mistake was the fact that things got worse before they got better ... And we backed out when things got worse.
FreedomBeforeEquality says2015-06-19T11:40:26.4210372-05:00
That is the obvious mistake that we need to learn from all this. Sequestering ourselves and staying out of matters like this before they blow up into huge world wars is a lesson we should have learned already from past wars. I didn't think we were so far separated from those events already that you'd suggest we sit here and mind our own business while countries led by people like that seize surrounding nations. (I'm looking at the Russia/Crimea incident too here ... It is not exclusive).
FreedomBeforeEquality says2015-06-19T11:41:30.0385812-05:00
Im not a fan of waiting to load your gun until the bear is already on top of you.
TBR says2015-06-19T11:47:20.0005905-05:00
11:36 - I am happy to leave the oil in that regent. The only path off dependence is necessity. As for the people, we have NEVER helped, only hurt more. I can feel for their suffering and know that we are not the proper help. A better solution MIGHT be to loosen immigration policy's for immigrants from that region.
TBR says2015-06-19T11:48:38.2828959-05:00
11:40 - That is EXACTLY what I am suggesting. When our efforts only further hurt the region, it is best to DO NOTHING!
TBR says2015-06-19T11:49:26.7062271-05:00
11:41 - I see no "loaded gun". The only thing close to that is the guns WE take there. We are a huge part of the problem, not the solution.
FreedomBeforeEquality says2015-06-19T11:53:10.9761399-05:00
And when you do nothing, you end up in a situation like the one we had in WWII where dictators seize a bunch of free nations that would have suffered much less and been more apt to help you (= less casualties on your side) when you finally get thrust into war against your will.
FreedomBeforeEquality says2015-06-19T11:57:46.1436373-05:00
We aren't making AK's and RPG's over here in the states for export. Theyre getting those from other enemy nations.
FreedomBeforeEquality says2015-06-19T12:00:50.2957728-05:00
If you think we are the only ones playing their cards in that region, youre sadly mistaken. That country is an extension of a bigger enemy. It's sad but necessary that we even have to go there directly to face the issue ... Our enemies were able to make their mark without committing troops because we left them to it long enough for them to make the country into what it is today. Thats what waiting and minding your own business does.
TBR says2015-06-19T12:29:55.2361287-05:00
11:53 - The middle-east is NOT pre-WWII Europe. In fact, many of the problems of the middle-east have direct roots in the failure in that region during/after WWII.
TBR says2015-06-19T12:30:19.5354623-05:00
11:57 - So what? I don't see how that changes anything!
TBR says2015-06-19T12:31:14.6572560-05:00
12:00 - Just because others muck in the area does not mean we must. A constant error on our part.
FreedomBeforeEquality says2015-06-19T15:38:56.1888549-05:00
"11:57 - So what? I don't see how that changes anything!" Youre implying that we are providing the guns. Ive never been shot at by an enemy holding an american caliber rifle before.
tajshar2k says2015-06-19T15:39:35.1584043-05:00
You were in the army?
FreedomBeforeEquality says2015-06-19T15:45:32.0776680-05:00
"11:53 - The middle-east is NOT pre-WWII Europe. In fact, many of the problems of the middle-east have direct roots in the failure in that region during/after WWII." How is 'Eastern superpowers expanding their territorial claim' not in some way like Germans expanding theirs? I suppose incidents like the Cuban missile crisis were unfounded also. Because some country began acting like the puppet of a superpower and showed hostility in their place towards us. Its a pretty convenient way to attack someone.
TBR says2015-06-20T17:54:51.8003791-05:00
I implied no such thing, you misunderstood.
TBR says2015-06-20T17:56:31.9855057-05:00
I don't give ISIL the credit of Germany . The fact stands that we NEVER have "helped" only "hurt" the middle-east.
58539672 says2015-06-20T20:04:02.8553771-05:00
The Kurds are fairly thankful for our intervention in the middle east. Then again when your ruler starts ethnically cleansing your people with mustard gas and mass executions, your moral bar of what a foreign intervention force does is lowered just a bit.
58539672 says2015-06-20T20:37:18.3842098-05:00
Though people often criticize him for starting the war, Bush actually did a fairly good job with our involvement in the middle east. Conflicts were limited to simple insurgencies in Iraq and skirmishes in the mountains of Afghanistan and Pakistan. Other than that the middle east was fairly stable. The Obama administration has... A bit of a longer list. Syria, Iraq (again), Yemen, Libya, Afghanistan (continued), Lebanon, Algeria, and Egypt. Their are also minor incidents in nearly ever other country in the region (Oman is going well though). Say what you will about Bush, but Obama's foreign policy simply sucks.
FreedomBeforeEquality says2015-06-22T23:30:45.8385130-05:00
"The fact stands that we NEVER have "helped" only "hurt" the middle-east." That could only be said after we pulled out prematurely ... And it'd still be an incorrect statement, even then.
TBR says2015-06-22T23:54:13.1709928-05:00
Not like its a good number, but <100k Kurds were killed vs the 140K+ CIVILIAN deaths (200k+ total) https://www.iraqbodycount.org/. We are not making Sadam look that bad.
TBR says2015-06-22T23:55:48.5557626-05:00
@FreedomBeforeEquality - How long to you want to occupy? To what end? No, we have messed-up everything we touch in the middle-east. Time to leave it alone.
FreedomBeforeEquality says2015-06-23T00:09:22.0958073-05:00
I can't say how long it would take ... Till we reached a point where they could effectively defend and govern themselves would be nice. In the mean time we get plenty of training and military development/scientific development. All good things. Its nice to have a vetted force familiar in tactics needed for the region too.
58539672 says2015-06-23T14:13:14.6541574-05:00
If we leave our other operations in the middle east (mainly Afghanistan), the same thing that happened to Iraq will happen to those areas to. Their is simply no one that can fill the power gap that the US would leave other than terror groups. The US is currently the only one keeping peace (or at least order) in the region.
FreedomBeforeEquality says2015-08-25T14:57:51.8827855Z
We've tried to get their own people to fill that power gap by training police forces and such. Ill tell you though ... Those people have zero motivation to police themselves. Its sad to say really that the only people with any motivation to do something about the state of their own country and government have all already been recruited into the terrorist organizations ranks. The regular people there are too scared or easily convinced letting their rebel neighbors still operate right under their noses. To them its a civil war, and they arent prepared to bring their brothers and neighbors to justice for the crimes they are committing.

Freebase Icon   Portions of this page are reproduced from or are modifications based on work created and shared by Google and used according to terms described in the Creative Commons 3.0 Attribution License.

By using this site, you agree to our Privacy Policy and our Terms of Use.