Which of these four principles of international law is the most important?

Posted by: joepbr

Of the four principles stated here, which one do you think that should be defended by the international community in cases in which two or more of them are conflicting?

Vote
18 Total Votes
1

Human Rights

The idea that every human being have some fundamental rights that should be defended independently of the political or social organization of their communities.
13 votes
1 comment
2

State sovereignity

State sovereignty is based on the idea that countries should be free to deal with their internal issues the way they think its best, without any type of uncalled interventions (economical, political, or military) between nations, and that maintainin... g the territorial integrity and union of a nation is one of the most basic principles of international law   more
3 votes
1 comment
3

National self-determination

Self-determination is the idea that every community has the right to decide how they want to organize their own political and social lives, even if in order to achieve it, they must oppose the authority that rules over them.
2 votes
1 comment
4

Democracy/Constitutional governance

The idea that forms of governments similar to a democracy should be defended and/or promoted around the world, since the best form of organizing a government is through a system under the authority of a constitution that restricts the powers of lead... ers, based on the idea that such leaders are mere representatives of their communities and should be accountable to it. This is based on the idea that democracies don't fight each other, and therefore, it's promotion is a way to achieve world peace   more
0 votes
0 comments
Leave a comment...
(Maximum 900 words)
Juan_Pablo says2014-06-29T23:37:42.2638562-05:00
Human Rights and Democratic/Constitutional Governance are the most important.
joepbr says2014-06-29T23:40:23.0218562-05:00
What if they are conflicting (for example, if a nation if violates human rights while promoting democracy)? Which of the two would be the most important?
PreferNotToBeLabeled says2014-06-30T00:36:59.6775306-05:00
Human rights hands down. There's no way anything else is more important.
ChosenWolff says2014-06-30T02:22:14.1025850-05:00
Democracy isn't a principle of international law, although 'm considering voting for that. A true democracy, isn't representative like Switzerland and Taiwan. Raw vote by the people can never fail.
ChosenWolff says2014-06-30T02:24:53.6118197-05:00
Joepbr is right. In not so rare cases, the people can have a democratic vote to harm a certain minority. Or in America's complex representative system of electoral college and redistricting, we allow the minority (conservatives) to abuse the majority (liberals, homosexual, Mexican, and African voting bloc.) Democracy done right can't fail. So many states treat it like a bureaucracy though.
Formerland1 says2014-07-01T11:58:19.2888387-05:00
If the majority are conservatives why are the liberals in power.
joepbr says2014-07-01T12:26:35.0018473-05:00
@ChosenWolff democracy isn't an explicit principle of international law, but several scholars consider it an "implicit" one, claiming that international law can only be effective with democracies.
ChosenWolff says2014-07-01T12:27:27.1373815-05:00
IMO, self determination can actually solve human rights 80% of the time. Not always, but a lot of the time.

Freebase Icon   Portions of this page are reproduced from or are modifications based on work created and shared by Google and used according to terms described in the Creative Commons 3.0 Attribution License.

By using this site, you agree to our Privacy Policy and our Terms of Use.